A well-made piece of fine jewelry is a beautiful gift that will stand the test of time. Fine jewelry will make your loved one feel special now and serve as an asset in their jewelry box for many years to come. 

With the holiday season just around the corner, we’ve rounded up our top jewelry gift ideas to help you easily find the perfect gift for everyone on your list. We’re sharing our top picks under $500, $1,000, and $2,500, so you’re sure to find a special piece no matter your budget.

Jewelry Gifts Under $500 

Diamond Initial Pendant Necklace

A diamond initial pendant necklace is a classic piece that will add a personal touch to their daily attire. Choose their favorite precious metal and your choice of initial. You can select their first or last initial, or choose multiple initials that spell out a unique message. 

Gemstone Stud Earrings

Gemstone stud earrings are an ideal gift option if you’re shopping for a fine jewelry classic on a budget. Our gemstone studs can be set with your choice of blue sapphires, emeralds, rubies, pink sapphires, or moissanites. Sapphires, emeralds, and rubies are perfect for adding a pop of color to an ensemble, while moissanite is a sparkly colorless stone that looks strikingly similar to diamonds. 

Black Diamond Stud Earrings

Luxe and mysterious, black diamond stud earrings are an excellent gift for someone with a bold sense of style. Stick with solitaire studs for a more classic effect or go for an on-trend fashion style

Shop more gifts under $500 for a lasting holiday gift that will be a reminder of your affection daily. 

Jewelry Gifts Under $1,000 

Diamond Tennis Bracelet 

If you’re looking for a gift that’s guaranteed to please, consider a diamond tennis bracelet. Our lower carat tennis designs offer timeless beauty on a budget, while our higher carat options are beautiful statement pieces. Whichever design you choose, a diamond tennis bracelet is a gift they’re sure to love. 

Huggie Hoop Earrings 

Diamond hoop earrings are a gorgeous gift that will elevate any outfit. For maximum wearability, we suggest choosing a pair of huggie hoops, like this classic half inch hoop design. Huggie hoops can be worn with everything from a ballgown to jeans and a t-shirt. Hoop earrings are a timeless gift idea and popular for everyday wear. 

Stackable Diamond Ring

A stackable diamond ring is a versatile gift that can be mixed and matched with other rings to create endless stylish combinations. Your loved one can wear it with fashion rings or alongside their wedding rings as a way of freshening up their bridal stack. 

These keepsake jewelry gift ideas under $1,000 are timeless and popular selections for holiday gift ideas. 

Jewelry Gifts Under $2,500 

Lab Diamond Jewelry 

Put a smile on their face this holiday season by choosing lab diamond jewelry in a classic design, like solitaire lab diamond studs or a solitaire lab diamond pendant necklace

Lab diamonds are real diamonds with the same chemical makeup as mined diamonds, yet they have a significantly lower price point. This lower price point makes lab diamond jewelry a more accessible option–even when looking at pieces with a higher carat weight. 

In the under $2,500 price range, you can get a beautiful piece of jewelry featuring around 2 carats of lab-grown diamonds. You could opt for an eye-catching pair of earrings or a gorgeous lab diamond necklace. You could also spread those carats around and dazzle your loved one with a matching earring and necklace set. 

Pave Diamond Hoop Earrings

Help your loved one shine bright with a glittering pair of pave diamond hoop earrings. We love this one inch micro pave design, which offers versatility while still having a stand-out look. With a subtle size, a classic shape, and 200 round cut diamonds, these hoops are a classic piece with a luxe touch.

Shop Holiday Jewelry Deals 

Still looking for the perfect holiday gifts for your loved ones? Find more giftable fine jewelry on our 2023 deals page, featuring great values on timeless diamond and gemstone jewelry. These sparkling gifts are gifts from the heart that last for generations.

Shop Jewelry Deals